Introducing ayayay…, a new bar & oven from Chef Akhtar Nawab and restaurateur Michael Wetherbee, the team behind Alta Calidad, the beloved Mexican restaurant in Prospect Heights, Brooklyn. Now open at 554 Vanderbilt Avenue in the former Wayward Fare space, ayayay… is a welcoming neighborhood gathering place along one of Brooklyn’s busiest dining corridors, boasting one of New York City’s few remaining wood-burning brick ovens. The restaurant serves an eclectic array of European-inspired comfort food, including its signature ayayay… Butter Burger and Fries, and Steak ’n Eggs Toast with salmoriglio, alongside a lively cocktail and wine program.
A Neighborhood Bar & Oven
Named for the familiar Spanish expression “ayayay,” often used to express life’s everyday frustrations, ayayay… is a place to let go of the day and settle into an easy night out. Whether stopping by for an impromptu drink at the bar, sharing a few plates with friends, or grabbing a casual dinner before heading across the street to Barclays Center, it’s designed for whatever the evening calls for.
Food
Drawing on three decades of experience in acclaimed New York kitchens, including Gramercy Tavern, Craft, and Craftbar, Chef Akhtar Nawab brings a playful, European-inspired approach to comfort food at ayayay…, layering familiar favorites with unexpected flavors.
Chef Nawab encourages guests to mix and match shared snacks and small plates, from Duck Fat and Smoked Butter Popcorn and Curried Marcona Almonds to Georgian Cheesy Bread with mushrooms and a quail egg and Spicy Lamb Sausage-Stuffed Pappadew Peppers. For a more substantial meal, larger plates include the ayayay… Butter Burger and Fries, Steak ’n Eggs Toast with salmoriglio, Hanger Steak Frites, and Pork Belly, while desserts round out the menu with Lemon Madeleines and Chef Pablo’s ice cream and sorbet.
Beverage
Overseen by partner Michael Wetherbee, ayayay…’s beverage program features an approachable wine list spanning varietals from Italy, France, Germany, Portugal, and California, including sparkling, white, skin-contact, rosé, and red wines. With selections ranging from $14–$24 per glass, the list offers sips for every occasion.
The cocktail menu features six classic cocktails alongside creative signatures, including the Olive Branch Martini, made with vodka, gin, Cocchi, and olive oil, and a customizable Martini Your Way. Beer offerings range from IPAs to pilsners and lagers, while non-alcoholic options include N/A Prosecco and a house-made Rosé Limonada featuring Seedlip, ginger, lime, rose liqueur, and non-alcoholic sparkling wine.
Design
Martina Guandalini drew inspiration from traditional European wine bars when creating the design of the restaurant's nine-bar and 30-seat intimate footprint. Walnut wood wainscoting, olive-green banquettes, cream ceramic tiles, and a black-and-white patterned linoleum floor evoke nostalgia, with a metallic plaster bar adding a subtle contemporary touch. At the wood- burning brick oven’s feature wall, a hand-painted mural by Mexican-born, Brooklyn-based artist Fernanda Uribe brings an element of local artistic collaboration and individuality, complemented by handmade circular tiles whose subtle irregularities celebrate the beauty of craftsmanship and give the space its own distinctive character.
Emails The PR Net team only — for jobs, use Apply Here on the listing.