Looking to add a beautiful pre-owned piece of jewelry to your collection? Navigating this space can be fun and exciting, especially the part where you discover gorgeous gems and the stories behind them. Shopping for pre-loved jewels can also be a bit confusing and even intimidating, so we consulted the experts for their advice. Read on for the most important tips to follow when shopping for pre-owned jewelry, straight from the safest and most stylish platforms out there.
Cartier Panthère Bracelet, CIRCA
Make sure you're buying authentic pieces from a trusted source.
“The best vintage jewelry stores will have gemologists and jewelry historians on staff and will be able to answer all of your questions about the styles you are considering. Check for positive online reviews and plenty of information about each piece on their website.” -Nicole Corsini, Marketing Manager, Lang Antique & Estate Jewelry
“When shopping for pre-owned luxury, you’ll want to make sure what you’re considering is authentic. Some pre-owned items may come with original paperwork and packaging. This can give confidence when considering a purchase. However, original collateral material is often separated from authentic pre-owned items. While we now treasure original paperwork, it wasn’t always the case that the original owner did. Rare are the highly trained specialists with knowledge, experience, and expertise to authenticate jewelry and precious gemstones, with or without original documentation. So it’s best to find a trusted, reputable company specializing in fine jewelry to ensure that what you’re buying is genuine. Do some research on the company you’re buying from and check with the BBB and review sites to see what others are saying about the seller.” -CIRCA
“Especially as jewelry can be so expensive, you should ensure that you are avoiding counterfeits or faux metals and stones. At Vestiaire Collective, we offer authentication and quality control services for all of our buyers and have jewelry experts available at our hubs in New York, Paris & Hong Kong to check your piece before you receive it.” -Sandrine Baudet, Manager of RTW, Accessories & Jewelry, Vestiaire Collective
Lang Antique & Estate Jewelry
Focus on condition.
"It may be expected that some pre-owned items can show signs of wear consistent with age, and that’s okay. In fact, the patina on a vintage bracelet may even add to its charm and desirability. You won’t want to polish off the warm glow natural to a gold or silver item that only comes with age. While some pre-owned jewels will be in better shape than others, it’s possible to find items in like-new condition. At the time of purchase, take care to note any condition issues or damage that may be beyond repair. For signed pieces, collectible watches, and iconic period jewelry in particular, modifications from the original condition can severely affect value. It’s a good idea to check the seller’s fine print and return policy. The instant an item arrives and is not in the condition described, or if you find it doesn’t quite suit your style, you’ll want to be able to return it with convenience and ease.” -CIRCA
Find the best value.
“There are a few companies that sell pre-owned jewelry, but the key is where to find the best value. Again, do some research. Brick and mortar retailers have higher fixed costs and margins, so it’s possible the price you pay there may be higher than it would be elsewhere. Auction houses may offer great value, and you may get lucky and find what you’re looking for at good price. But be careful. It takes a savvy and aggressive type to bid against others who may have more knowledge than you do. Many shoppers have turned to online retailers to find pre-owned jewelry they are looking for. Reputable and trusted online sellers with a global sales presence are best able to offer a wide selection of coveted pieces for competitive prices, which means you’ll be able to purchase that Cartier Love bracelet you’ve had your eye on for, well, a price you’ll love.” -CIRCA
“We have an extensive catalog of amazing pieces at almost any price point. It's easy to filter based on condition, model and price to find a beautiful piece that fits your budget from almost any designer brand. Our app makes it easy to filter and sort different brands and models, so you can reference what the current market pricing is for many different eras, designers, stones and metals.” -Sandrine Baudet, Manager of RTW, Accessories & Jewelry, Vestiaire Collective
Cartier Nigéria Yellow Gold Ring, Vestiaire Collective
Buy what you love!
“The great thing about vintage jewelry is that each piece is so unique - you're certain to find a design that speaks to you. Although signed pieces are sometimes more valuable for resale, don't be afraid to buy a gorgeous unsigned piece that you'll wear all the time and enjoy.” -Nicole Corsini, Marketing Manager, Lang Antique & Estate Jewelry
