Supermodel Heidi Klum celebrated the third anniversary of Crazy Pizza in New York City’s SoHo neighborhood, bringing together a star-studded group of friends ahead of her iconic annual Halloween party.

Guests included Sofia Vergara, Lindsey Vonn, Taylor Momsen, Christian Siriano, Kyle MacLachlan, Karen Mulder, Leni Klum, Henry Samuel, Johan Samuel, Lorraine Schwartz, and others who gathered for an evening of Halloween-inspired cocktails, Crazy Pizza’s signature Italian dishes, and a special performance by Jacob Lusk.

Among the evening’s highlights was the limited-edition Heidi Klum x Butterfinger dessert pizza, a special Halloween creation featuring Crazy Pizza’s signature dough topped with chocolate and peanut butter sauce, Butterfinger pieces, and pumpkin-shaped meringues.

Image credit: Slaven Vlasic/Getty Images for Heidi Klum